Why plants grow better with CO2

Perhaps you remember our post Why is carbon dioxide (CO2) the most important plant nutrient in the aquarium? , which was preceded by the series The story of liquid CO2 fertilisation ?

In the course of our tests we were able to gather some measuring data which we don't want to keep from you.

The discussion, whether aquariums also work without CO2, is as old as modern aquatics itself. One thing is clear: aquatic plants need carbon for their growth. Of course, aquariums also function without CO2 but in comparison the plants look weaker and duller and they don’t grow as vigorously. Several plants cannot be cultivated at all without CO2. This limits the choice of plants. A foreground lawn or a red eye-catcher in the aquarium would be unthinkable without CO2.

The easiest way to make it clear is with a comparison of the biomass. For that reason we set up three aquariums and determined the initial weight of the plants, which was identical in all aquariums (species/weight).

Aquarium 1: blank test without CO2, lighting 48 W (2 x 24 W JBL SOLAR TROPIC T5 ULTRA, 24-39 W fluorescent tubes) on aquarium with 63 l gross volume.

Aquarium 2: with a PROFLORA Bio CO2 system, lighting 48 W (2 x 24 W JBL SOLAR TROPIC T5 ULTRA, 24-39 W fluorescent tubes) on aquarium with 63 l gross volume.

Aquarium 3: with a compressed gas PROFLORA CO2 plant care system, lighting 48 W (2 x 24 W JBL SOLAR TROPIC T5 ULTRA, 24-39 W fluorescent tubes) on aquarium with 63 l gross volume.

The initial weight of the test plants had a drained net weight of 300 g (which means moist but without dropping water anymore). After 4 weeks the aquariums were emptied, the plants (incl. roots) carefully removed from the bottom material and the algae from the plant mass, as far as this was possible. The drained net weight was determined, as before the setting up. The aquarium was fertilised with JBL PROFLORA Ferropol to ensure the trace element supply.

Blank test without CO2 supply JBL BioCO2 JBL compressed gas system
Initial weight plants [g] 300 300 300
Final weight biomass in total [g] 320 440 840
Final weight algae [g] 76 0 7.1
Final weight plants [g] 244 440 832.9

The blank test (average CO2 content in water 6-8 mg/l CO2) showed only a small increase of biomass of 20 g in total. The actual plant biomass decreased by 9 % (56 g), whereas the algae biomass increased to 76 g. Even if you can’t transfer the results to all aquariums (especially for those with weaker lighting) in general, this shows clearly that it resulted in a shift of plant-based biomass (reduction of taller plants, significant increase in algae). The leaf distance of the stem plants, the leaf colour and the stem structure varied greatly to the plants in the CO2 supplied aquariums and had a rather weak and dull impression. If a plant aquarium is left to function without CO2, there will only be very simple, low-growing plants left and there will be a great risk of algae formation.

The aquarium with bio-CO2 supply reached an average CO2 content of 20-24 mg/l CO2 over the test period. Here you can discern an evident increase of 46% from 300 g to 440 g (equivalent to 140 g increase) and no visible increase in algae.

In the aquarium where the CO2 supply was adjusted to about 38-40 mg/l CO2 through a compressed gas system (controlled by the JBL PROFLORA pH-Control Touch ) you could discern more than a doubling of the biomass by 177 % (approx. 533 g) in the taller aquarium plants. Only a low amount of 7.1 g algae could be removed from this aquarium at the end of the test, and this was of no statistical or optical importance because of the strong increase of the plant biomass.

Granted, the third aquarium with the compressed gas system was producing large amounts of CO2, because the average recommendations lie between 20 and 25 mg/l CO2 (or extended between 15 and 35 mg/l). Therefore in practice, as controlled during the auto pH mode on the JBL PROFLORA pH-Control Touch , CO2 contents of 20-25 mg/l are set, which are sufficient to ensure very good plant growth at average lighting intensity.

Based on the results you can see that the differences are marked. Even the aquarium without CO2 has changed- but with quite a lot more algae mass and very low plant growth. The leaf distance of the stem plants, the leaf colour and the stem structure varied greatly to the plants in the CO2 supplied aquariums and had a rather weak and dull impression. If a plant aquarium is left to function without CO2, there will only be very simple, low-growing plants left and there will be a great risk of algae formation.

© 31.08.2016
Matthias Wiesensee
Matthias Wiesensee
M.Sc. Wirtschaftsinformatik

Social Media, Online Marketing, Homepage, Kundenservice, Problemlöser, Fotografie, Blogger, Tauchen, Inlineskating, Aquaristik, Gartenteich, Reisen, Technik, Elektronische Musik

About me: Seit Teenagerzeiten mit Aquarien in Kontakt. Klassische Fischaquarien, reine Pflanzenaquarien bis hin zum Aquascape. Aber auch ein Gartenteich und Riffaquarien begleiten mich privat im Hobby. Als Wirtschaftsinformatiker, M.Sc. bin ich als Online Marketing Manager bei JBL für die Bereiche Social Media, Webentwicklung und der Kommunikation mit dem Anwender der JBL Produkte zuständig und kenne die JBL Produkte im Detail.

Comments

Hinweise und Einwilligung zu Cookies & Drittinhalten

Wir verwenden technisch notwendige Cookies/Tools um diesen Dienst anzubieten, zu betreiben und abzusichern. Des Weiteren verwenden wir mit Deiner ausdrücklichen Einwilligung Cookies/Tools zum Marketing, Tracking, Erstellen personalisierter Inhalte auf Drittseiten sowie zur Darstellung von Drittinhalten auf unserer Webseite. Eine von Dir erteilte Einwilligung, kannst Du jederzeit mit Wirkung für die Zukunft über den Menüpunkt „Cookie-Einstellungen“ widerrufen.
Mit dem Klick auf „Alle erlauben“ erteilst Du uns die ausdrückliche Einwilligung zur Verwendung von Cookies/Tools um die Qualität und Performance unseres Dienstes zu verbessern, zur funktionalen und personalisierten Leistungsoptimierung, die Effektivität unserer Anzeigen oder Kampagnen zu messen, für personalisierte Inhalte zu Marketingzwecken, auch außerhalb unserer Webseite. Dies ermöglicht uns personalisierte Online-Anzeigen und erweiterte Analysemöglichkeiten über Dein Nutzerverhalten. Dies beinhaltet auch den Zugriff und die Speicherung von Daten auf Deinem Gerät. Deine Einwilligung kannst Du jederzeit mit Wirkung für die Zukunft über den Menüpunkt „Cookie-Einstellungen“ widerrufen.
Über die Schaltfläche „Einstellungen ändern“ kannst Du individuelle Einwilligungen zu den Cookies/Tools erteilen, widerrufen und erhältst weitergehende Informationen zu den von uns eingesetzten Cookies/Tools, deren Zwecke und Laufzeiten.
Mit dem Klick auf „Nur unbedingt erforderlich“ werden nur technisch notwendige Cookies/Tools eingesetzt.

Our data protection declaration tells you how we process personal data and what purposes we use the data processing for.

PUSH messages from JBL

What are PUSH messages? As part of the W3C standard, web notifications define an API for end-user notifications that are sent to the user's desktop and/or mobile devices via the browser. Notifications appear on the end devices as they are familiar to the end user from apps installed on the device (e.g. emails). Notifications appear on the end user’s device, just like an app (e.g. for emails) installed on the device.

These notifications enable a website operator to contact its users whenever they have a browser open - it doesn’t matter whether the user is currently visiting the website or not.

To be able to send web push notifications, all you need is a website with a web push code installed. This allows brands without apps to take advantage of many of the benefits of push notifications (personalised real-time communications at just the right moment).

Web notifications are part of the W3C standard and define an API for end user notifications. A notification makes it possible to inform the user about an event, such as a new blog post, outside the context of a website.

JBL GmbH & Co. KG provides this service free of charge, and it is easy to activate or deactivate.